How far is Brexit responsible?

Empty tomato crates at Tesco

Empty tomato crates at Tesco

A few of the UK’s greatest supermarkets are limiting gross sales of tomatoes and different salad gadgets.

The federal government says the shortages, that are anticipated to final for a number of weeks, have been “predominantly brought on by poor climate in Spain and North Africa the place they’re produced”.

Different highlights the impression of excessive vitality costs on UK growers, whether or not the federal government has finished sufficient to assist them and grocery store pricing.

Numerous individuals on social media have additionally been posting photos of empty cabinets within the UK and contrasting them with loads of recent produce in supermarkets in Europe, claiming Brexit is an element.

So, what’s the proof for this?

What are provides like in Europe?

The European Fee (EC) informed us that “there isn’t a specific scenario of meals scarcity in EU agricultural markets”.

The Spanish authorities did verify that “provides in Spain are at present decrease”.

It mentioned this was largely because of the climate: “unusually excessive temperatures from the tip of the summer season interval till December”… adopted by a “sudden arrival of low temperatures in January… resulted in a drop in provide”.

There have been some shortages within the Republic of Eire, one other European Union (EU) member, and Irish retailers have blamed freezing climate in Southern Europe and North Africa. However none are rationing fruit and greens.

How is Brexit affecting tomato imports from the EU?

EU international locations are within the single market – a large, free-trade zone the place international locations share the identical guidelines and laws.

The UK is not within the single market and now has a rule that each consignment of “plant merchandise” – comparable to tomatoes – despatched from the EU to the UK, requires customs declarations and pre-notification on the federal government’s IT system.

It produced a video on how to do that, utilizing an instance of somebody making an attempt to import tomatoes.

The federal government says the paperwork will not be routinely checked however, from 2024, there shall be additional paperwork and checks.

A screenshot of a frame from the government's animated video showing a character called Ali who imports tomatoes from Spain

A authorities video exhibits the steps the character referred to as Ali has to take to import tomatoes from Spain.

We spoke to MCE Logistics, an organization which processes these kinds for dozens of importers of Spanish tomatoes for British supermarkets.

It informed us it takes round 10-20 minutes to do that per lorry – longer if they’re transporting combined a great deal of greens – and so they use specialised software program.

Man Singh-Watson who runs the Riverford veg field firm, and has farms in England and France, blames “Brexit paperwork” for the shortages.

Brexit represents “a problem for the whole Spanish fruit and vegetable sector”, based on the Spanish authorities.

But it surely mentioned the present tomato shortages within the UK have been “because of the climate causes talked about, and to not Brexit”.

We requested the European Fee whether or not Brexit was an element. It didn’t touch upon this, however mentioned “meals costs and commerce flows are pushed by market forces”.

One individual on social media highlighted the scenario within the Netherlandsone other supply of tomatoes for the UK.

They quoted ‘Daniel’ saying: “Now we have too many tomatoes! We used to export them to the UK nevertheless it now takes a truck driver 77 hours of queuing to take tomatoes to the UK and all truck drivers merely refuse.”

We contacted the business associations within the Netherlands in addition to the haulage firm pictured within the tweet.

The corporate has not received again to us and the business affiliation mentioned they have been “not conscious of queuing on the ports within the Netherlands for items leaving to or getting into from the UK”.

Ksenija Simovic, a senior coverage adviser at Copa-Cogeca, a gaggle which represents farmers and farming co-operatives within the EU, mentioned when there’s a scarcity of provide “it does not assist that the UK is out of the EU and single market”.

“However I do not assume that is the first motive the UK is having shortages,” Ms Simovic added.

We requested the UK authorities if Brexit was an element nevertheless it didn’t deal with this level.

It mentioned farming minister Mark Spencer had spoken to UK retailers and “…requested them to look once more at how they work with our farmers and the way they purchase fruit and greens”.

What concerning the UK’s tomato producers?

Of all of the tomatoes eaten within the UK – about 500,000 tonnes a 12 months – UK growers produce a fifth or 100,000 tonnes.

Through the summer season, this goes as much as round half of all of the tomatoes purchased.

Picture of tomatoes in a box with a Union Jack

Image of tomatoes in a field with a Union Jack

There have been shortages of seasonal farm employees, together with within the glasshouses the place tomatoes are grown, which were blamed on Brexit and the pandemic.

the authorities’s seasonal employees visa scheme permits employees to remain for six months at a time. Earlier than Brexit, they might come and go – from different EU international locations – as a part of freedom of motion guidelines. Now they arrive from international locations as distant as Nepal.

Bal Kumar Khatri (r) and brother Buddi Bahadur Khatri (l) from Nepal

Seasonal employees Buddi Bahadur Khatri (l) and Bal Kumar Khatri (r) got here from Nepal to work in glasshouses final 12 months.

Dr Sarah Schiffling, a provide chain knowledgeable from the Hanken College in Helsinki, informed us the season for rising tomatoes in UK glasshouses is about 9 months a 12 months. A six-month visa means recruiting and coaching two units of employees, including to the paperwork and value.

As well as, visas are granted provided that employees earn a minimum of £10.10 for every hour labored – 60p greater than the present Nationwide Minimal Scale.

Dr Schiffling mentioned the distinction in pricing methods between UK and EU supermarkets was an element within the present shortages.

“The EU supermarkets use ‘spot charges’ – when there are fewer tomatoes the worth goes up, when there are heaps then the worth goes down.”

In distinction, she mentioned, some UK supermarkets tie producers to longer-term, fixed-price contracts and “that turns into a problem if the producers’ prices rise quickly, is it price it for them to nonetheless provide these supermarkets?”.

What about tomatoes from Morocco?

Greater than a 3rd of tomatoes eaten within the UK at present come from Morocco.

UK tomato imports in 2022: 35% Morocco, 34% Netherlands, 16% Spain and 15% other EU countries

UK tomato imports in 2022: 35% Morocco, 34% Netherlands, 16% Spain and 15% different EU international locations

Growers there have been affected by unusually chilly night-time temperatures that affected tomato ripening.

Dangerous climate additionally led to the cancellations of ferries bringing provides to the European mainland over the previous three to 4 weeks.

after brexit, the UK signed a commerce continuity settlement with Morocco (replicating the commerce deal the UK had with the nation as an EU member).

In March 2022, Poole Harbor introduced a brand new direct service connecting the UK and Morocco can be launched “shortly”.

It mentioned it might present “another route for exporters from Morocco and Africa at present utilizing highway networks to the UK through Europe”. However the route has not been launched.

We contacted officers at Poole however haven’t had a reply.

Reality check branding

Actuality verify branding

Leave a Comment